Introduction and Purpose The topic assigned for my bibliography was children and the Internet culture. I narrowed the topic to moral and ethical aspects and how those relate to Internet usage by youth. The bibliography titled, Issues Related to Youth Access of the Internet, provides useful resources for information professionals who work with students, parents and teachers and need to stay current on issues relating to cyberspace. The purpose of the bibliography is to present resources that explore what makes up the Internet culture and what different social groups are advocating with regard to free speech and use of censorship on the Internet. Youth access to information is dependent upon freedom of speech and opposition to censorship. Information professionals will be asked to advise students, parents and teachers in determining what is helpful or what is harmful on the Internet. The resources listed provide an overview of available materials that will direct the reader to current information on Internet usage and access by children. Sub-topics within the bibliography include an overview of the Internet culture and specific areas of concern that will affect youth access to information, such as legal issues on the Internet, and freedom of expression which includes freedom of speech, censorship and cyberporn. Overview of Search Procedures Since my topic revolves around the Internet, many of the resources I found were Internet sites that linked related sites . Debate on censorship and children's usage of the Internet is a very current topic, and with the passage of the Telecommunication bill (specifically the section that includes the Communication Decency Act), discussion on the Net is very active. The currency of the topic means that I found a limited number of books available while a large number of resources were found on the Internet as websites and on-line articles. The resources available on the Internet could be accessed by using search engines that allow keyword and boolean searches. The main search engines I used were Webcrawler and Yahoo. These searches provided several possible sites with summary information. Each site provided links to other sites with hypertext, and I bookmarked appropriate sites so that I could return at a later date. The following search terms used separately and combined aided my search: Internet, information superhighway, computer network(s),communication, computer mediated communication, children, culture, society, social aspects, moral and ethical aspects, ethics, freedom of speech, censorship, law. Interestingly, using Internet culture as a subect heading yielded almost no references. A boolean search using Internet and culture or Internet and society produced better results. I searched library card catalogs of the CARL system (primarily Denver Public Library and Auraria), EZ CAT (Aurora/Arapahoe online catalog), and FirstSearch (primarily World Cat and ERIC). Periodical searches were done on InfoTrac and by using keyword searches in on-line magazines on the Internet. Aside from the Internet sites, the resources listed were found in the Metropolitan Denver area due to time constraints and availability. However, most of the resources should be readily available through interlibrary loans whatever your location or directly accessible through the Internet. The Internet sites were invaluable resources since hypertext links made references cited immediately available for use. I searched many of the library databases from my home computer. This allowed me unlimited time to search the catalogs and find call numbers that would help me browse the shelves when I visited the libraries. I browsed shelves at the Denver Public Library, Aurora Central and Auraria in order to find appropriate materials. Browsing the catalog record of individual titles also helped me find additional subject headings to further my search. I attended a half day workshop at Denver Public Library on Children and the Internet, but while interesting, it did not provide me with any resources on the subject. Since the Internet is constantly changing, it is necessary for information professionals to stay current with the Internet culture and technology. I focused my searches within the last 5 years , and the majority of the resources included in the bibliography are very current. Annotation Information The annotations are divided into topic areas, and then listed alphabetically by author or by title if there was no author for the citation. Titles that are "must reads" will be bulleted. I have tried to find reviews for all the book annotations, but if this was not possible it is clearly stated in the annotation. Many of the Internet sites were recommended or linked by hypertext from a similar or related site. The annotation includes summary information about the work and tells why it has been included in the bibliography as a resource for the information professional. Each book annotation includes information about the author, and briefly lists their credentials. The annotation will indicate the format of the work (book, periodical, Internet site, etc.). Bibliographic information or a URL for Internet sites is included. Indexing is very important to the usefulness of material for the reader, so I make special note if the book has an index. In the case of Internet sites, I note if hypertext is utilized effectively or if the website has its own index page to assist the user in locating information. I also note the glossary, appendix or notes field at the end of the book if they are especially useful. Websites on the Internet often include glossaries and or primers about the subject they are discussing, and that is noted if it merits special consideration. The annotations included in this bibliography will provide the reader with a good overview of what makes up the Internet culture and what problems must be resolved in order to insure youth access to the Internet while protecting this on-line world from censorship. Issues Related to Youth Access of the Internet Internet Culture Goodman, Danny. Living at Light Speed. New York: Random House, 1994. This book provides one perspective on what the Internet is and what it may become. Danny Goodman is an award winning technology writer, the winner of Best Book awards from the Computer Press Association. Goodman examines the Information Superhighway and reflects on what lies ahead. He evaluates the true nature of the Information Superhighway separating hype from fact. Chapter 6, "The Dark Side," reveals potential hazards in the on-line world, including discussion of safety on the Net and censorship. The author advocates a plan of action that will enable consumers to have more control over what the Information Superhighway offers. The book is written for the layman and provides a good overview of the Internet. Glossary and index are included in the book. Book reviews in Library Journal, Publisher's Weekly and New Yorker recommended the book as a valuable guide and primer for those who are not technologically inclined. It is a good choice as an introduction to the on-line world and helps the reader sift through all the publicity about the information superhighway. Moore, Dinty W. The Emperor's Virtual Clothes: The Naked Truth about Internet Culture.Chapel Hill: Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill, 1995 This book was included because it gives an alternate, and somewhat offbeat perspective of the Internet culture through explicit examples. The reader tours the on-line world in the shoes of the author, and experiences many aspects of the Information Superhighway that one might not explore for themselves. The book is intended for the general reader. Also the author presents an opposing viewpoint of the impact of the Internet. He believes the Information Superhighway is here to stay, but will not become an all encompassing feature in our lives. The author explains that the Internet will ultimately be assimilated into society as were the telephone and the television without drastically changing basic human values. Moore feels that the Internet is a useful machine, but will not change human beings fundamentally. After exploring the virtual world of the Internet, he comes to the conclusion that the real world surpasses the on-line experience. Dinty W. Moore (swears its his real name) has worked as a film maker and a reporter for UPI. At present, he is an assistant professor at Penn State University's Altoona campus where he teaches writing. The book has a table of contents, but no index. There is a glossary at the end. The book received mixed reviews. One review took a negative stance, and said that the book was a "thin polemic" that took a skeptical look at the Internet (Publisher's Weekly, July 15, 1995, p.212). Another review recommended the book as a well written and humorous primer (Library Journal, August, 1995, p. 112). In any case, this book is recommended as an interesting side trip into the Internet culture. Negroponte, Nicholas. Being Digital. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1995 Negroponte discusses the spread of computing and digital communications, and his belief that the growth in these areas will dramatically impact society. Nicholas Negroponte is the founder and director for MIT's Media Laboratory that studies and researches future forms of human communication. Since he is considered an expert in the field of computer mediated communication, I've included his book to provide insight into what direction the future is heading through new technology. The author believes that the greatest social impact of on-line computer networks will be generational (6). Children more readily accept and adapt to the use of computers in their everyday life, and don't see it as novel or threatening. Negroponte says the Internet provides an excellent medium for children to "be heard and not seen" (202) while they learn about the world and find knowledge and meaning in a global environment. The book is thought provoking and written for the general reader. It is indexed. Book reviews in Library Journal, Publisher's Weekly, and Fortune all recommend this book. It is described as an upbeat primer on the information revolution (Publisher's Weekly, Jan. 16, 1995, p. 449). Rheingold, Howard. The Virtual Community: Homesteading on the Electronic Frontier. Reading: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1993. An informative book on the Internet culture written from the perspective of a long time user. The author participates in an on-line community known as the WELL (Whole Earth 'Lectronic Link) and has personal insights into the virtual world of the Internet. He discusses the development of the Internet culture from its beginnings to the present. Rheingold is a multimedia columnist for Publish magazine and has also written for The New York Times, Psychology Today, and Omni to name a few. He is regularly cited by authors of works relating to computer mediated communication. This book was chosen as a good source for understanding the Internet culture, and its ramifications with regard to society. The author discusses the value of community building and free expression on the Internet. He also explores the ways in which society may be changed through Internet usage. Rheingold believes one of the most positive aspects of the Internet is the opportunity it provides for people to form relationships in a global community. Bibliography and index are included in book. This book received very favorable reviews from Business Week (Dec. 20, 1993, p. 15) and Fortune (Feb. 7, 1994, p. 157). It is recommended for its descriptions of everyday life on the Net. Legal issues and the Internet American Library Association. http://www.ala.org (29 April '96). The homepage for the American Library Association is a good resource since it provides a link to a page set up by the ALA Office for Information Technology Policy titled, "Selected Readings on Internet Content Regulation" (http://www.ala.org/oitp.html). A reading list of current articles is presented that relates to intellectual freedom. Understanding these issues is paramount to information professionals concerned with pending legislation that may influence what information is accessible on the Internet. The reading list contains references to sources made available within the last six months. The ALA homepage also has an archive of documents that includes ALA Intellectual Freedom statements. The Library Bill of Rights, and the ALA interpretation of access to electronic information, services and networks are other examples of available documents. This site is recommended as an excellent on-line resource that provides current information related to legislation restricting access to materials on the Internet. The Battle Over Net Censorship. http://pathfinder.com (29 April '96) This page is an on-line information source for news on Net politics, and is regularly updated by Pathfinder, Time Warner's site. Current updates are provided on the legal battles ensuing over Internet censorship. Access to background information relating to this issue is also available. Background information on events leading up the passage of the Telecommunications Bill on February 8, 1996 can be found. This site also connects one to those opposing censorship legislation as well as to those supporting legislation to control free expression on the Internet. Information pertaining to the cyberporn controversy, such as the Carnegie Mellon study by Martin Rimm and the infamous Time article on cyberporn, is linked to this site with hypertext. Several critics of the Time cover story may be viewed through hypertext links also. This website was included as an additional information resource that provides an overview of the conflicts over Internet censorship, and is especially useful since it is regularly updated. Branscomb, Anne Wells. Who Owns Information? From Privacy to Public Access. New York: BasicBooks, New York, 1994. This book was chosen because the author discusses the legal aspects of providing access to information. It is related to free speech and censorship as it pertains to the control of information. The author explores what information is private and what information should be public knowledge. Branscomb's view is that society must come to an agreement on how to control (or not control) access to information. This is an insightful book on what information is, who owns it , and who should have access. A good read for information professionals dealing with issues of accessibility to information. Anne Wells Branscomb is a well respected communication and computer lawyer. She is a legal scholar-in-residence at Harvard University's Program on Information Resources Policy. The book is well researched and provides an extensive notes field at the back of the book citing sources. An index to the work is also provided. Anne Branscomb "demonstrates the glaring inadequacy of current laws to protect information assets and safeguard individual rights."(Publisher's Weekly, May 9,1994, p.58). Library Journal (July, 1994, p.111) also highly recommends this book for being well researched and an engrossing read. Cavazos, Edward and Gavino Morin. Cyberspace and the Law: Your Rights and Duties in the On-Line World. Cambridge: The MIT Press, 1994. A great resource that explains legal aspects related to the Internet. The authors are both lawyers associated with law firms in Texas, but have written a book for the lay person with little or no legal training. Chapter 5 and chapter 6 are especially relevant to free and uncensored access to information. Chapter 5 deals with the First Amendment and discusses how that relates to on-line activities. The authors specifically discuss censorship by system operators. Chapter 6 addresses sexually explicit material. Throughout the book, the authors analyze the issues in the traditional context (outside of cyberspace), and then apply the law to the on-line community. Problems are examined and possible solutions suggested. Notes field and an excellent appendix is included that lists resources for legal assistance, organizations involved with legal issues in cyberspace, statutes related to individual rights, etc. Good background information for the reader on legal issues related to Internet usage. Book is indexed. Booklist (Nov. 15, 1994, p. 560) recommends this book for its thorough descriptions on how our laws can affect the new communication revolution. Even though the authors are lawyers and use legal precedents in their arguments, this book provides clear and concise explanations for all readers. Sussman, Vic. "Policing Cyberspace," U.S. News & World Report, 118 (January 23, 1995), 54-60. This article discusses computer crime and the need for new laws to safeguard free speech and determine what kinds of "cyberspeech" should be made illegal (58). The author says the positive flow of information and the breakdown of communication hierarchies is a plus in the on-line world, but on the negative side, a situation is created that can victimize people with offensive speech or images and invade people's privacy. Police are asking for laws that give them greater power to control what happens on computer networks, but the Internet culture resists any regulating bodies that may infringe on freedom of expression. The article presents good information on the difficulties involved in controlling activities on the Internet. Turner, William Bennett. "What Part of 'No Law' Don't You Understand," Wired, 4.03, 1996. This article provides an explanation of the First Amendment, and its relation to the Internet by constitutional scholar and attorney, William Bennett Turner. Turner does not believe we need a new constitutional amendment for digital communication. He says the First Amendment is flexible enough to protect our freedoms. The author discusses Supreme Court decisions that relate to new media, such as the Red Lion decision that dealt with broadcasting. This decision upheld the FCC's Fairness Doctrine, which required licensed broadcasters to cover important societal issues and give contrasting viewpoints. Turner goes on to explain how the First Amendment in its original form can be applied to digital communication. This article provides excellent information on the First Amendment as well as the author's view that there is no need to propose a new amendment in order to respond to issues of digital communication. The article is recommended for its discussion of the First Amendment, and the presentation of the perspective that advocates the adequacy of the amendment in relation to regulating new media. Freedom of Expression Arbuss, Steve. "Free Expression, Copyright, and Democracy." http://www.paranoia.com/~ebola This on-line article outlines remarks presented by Steve Arbuss for The Ethics of the Internet Conference at U.C. Berkeley on November 11, 1995. The author believes the Internet has the potential to enhance society's freedom to consume information, and provides several benefits, such as enabling dialogue, inspiring creative solutions to problems and organizing accumulations of knowledge and ideas. Arbuss discusses Internet problems with copyright law and indecency legislation. Of particular interest to the information professional are the links to sites related to freedom of expression. The links to similar sites include information on the First Amendment, the Electronic Freedom Foundation, the Communication Decency Act, and so forth. Arbuss presents a good case for the positive aspects of the Internet, and its usefulness to society. Burstein, Daniel and David Kline. Road Warriors: Dreams and Nightmares Along the Information Superhighway. New York: A Dutton Book, 1995. Although this book is directed toward business and the global economy, the authors analyze social change and the information highway. They present their ideas about what the future holds in relation to the digital revolution. Chapter 4, "The Internet Reconsidered," is especially relevant to information professionals involved in the issues of ethics, pornography and freedom of expression. The chapter discusses control of access to information by parents and commercial providers, and the lack of a rule-making body regulating context on the Internet. The authors stress that this is a defining characteristic of the Internet--that there are no controls and many Internet users want it to remain an unrestricted environment. Notes providing bibliographic references and an index are included at the back of the book. Also Appendix B presents an interesting interview with several prominent participants involved with new technologies and the impact on society. Alvin Toffler and Paul Saffo are two of the participants. Discussion revolves around how technology will change our world in the 21st Century. Daniel Burstein and David Kline are well known writers. Daniel Burstein acts as advisor in investment banking and has written several books on the global economy. David Kline writes for Wired magazine and the on-line magazine Hot Wired. PC Magazine (Nov. 21, 1995, p. 69) praises this book for being intelligently written and an enjoyable read. Fortune (Nov. 13, 1995, p. 237) also recommends this title, but says there are some faults. The book reads more like a collection of articles than a cohesive novel, and the authors bounce from subject to subject. This review says that some of their conclusions read like clichÈs, but as a whole the book is "an intelligent primer on the technological issues of our day." (237) Censorship. http://www.tcom.ohiou.edu/OU-Language/project- censorship.html (29 April '96). This web site was chosen because it is an important resource for information on censorship and electronic communication. The site provides hypertext links to voices for censorship and voices against censorship. Information about opposing viewpoints is very useful to the information professional who needs to be aware of both sides of the censorship issue. Hypertext links you the Electronic Freedom Foundation homepage to view material against censorship. Access to voices for censorship include a hypertext link to an on-line article by Irving Kristol, "Pornography, Obscenity and the Case for Censorship," and a link to the Family Research Council, described as an activist conservative Christian organization. There is also a hypertext link for child safety on the Internet which connects one to a brochure authored by Lawrence J. Magid. The brochure is titled, "Child Safety on the Information Superhighway," and was prepared for the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. This site provides a link to Yahoo, which lists a directory of resources related to censorship and the Internet. Links related to the debate over Time's magazine article, "On a Screen Near You: Cyberporn," can be found on this site. Information on censorship in education and individual case studies are available. There is also a collection of search tools that relate to Internet issues on censorship, freedom of speech, the First Amendment, and academic freedom. This site is an excellent reference tool. Champelli, L. The Internet Advocate. http://www.silver.ucs.indiana.edu/~lchampel/netadv.htm (29 April '96). The Internet Advocate is an excellent resource guide designed primarily for librarians and educators. This web site offers ideas on ways to respond to inaccurate perceptions of porn on the net and pursue positive examples of youth Internet use. Hypertext links the information professional to additional Internet sites with related materials. A link to the Public Service Librarian's Professional Guide to Internet Resources gives instructions for subscribing to popular library listserves, such as KIDLIT, PUBYAC, LM-NET, etc. The link to the Eric Clearinghouse provides access to educational resources on the Net. The Internet Advocate provides information on acceptable use policy and on software products designed to block Internet sites that the user deems inappropriate. In addition, hypertext links are available to EFF (Electronic Freedom Foundation), ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) and the ALA (American Library Association). These are all organizations committed to electronic freedom of information. This web site is recommended for its content and numerous links to similar sites that provide information about freedom of expression on the Internet. Computer-Mediated Communication Magazine. January, 1996. http://www.december.com/cmc/mag/index.html The January 1996 issue was a special issue on the philosophical perspectives of computer-mediated communication. This issue was devoted to the accessibility of indecent material on the Internet and the philosophical issues underlying debates about free speech, pornography and censorship. The issue has many hypertext links that connect the reader to related ideas and issues. An article by Wes Cooper, "Wizards, Toads, and Ethics," delves into the moral implications involved in determining what is tolerated or not tolerated in cyberspace. Cooper believes a moral philosophy needs to be developed as users of the Net project and identify with what they create on the Internet (such as characters created for MUD's). Another on-line article, "Sexually Explicit Materials and the Internet," by Douglas Birsch discusses the regulation of obscenity. The author has two categorizes for sexually explicit materials and gives his definition for obscene and pornographic. He believes censorship of sexually explicit materials revolves around the right of liberty and advocates local or community control of such materials. The January 1996 issue presents valuable information on the philosophical issues related to freedom of expression. This is a useful resource for the information professional that aids in understanding the problems inherent to the creation of regulations concerning Internet usage. This on-line magazine is published and edited by John December. He is well known on the Net for specializing in the study of Internet-based Computer Mediated Communication. From his homepage (http://www.rpi.edu/~decemj/index.html), one can access a list of Internet information resources about the Internet and computer-mediated communication as well as a summary of Internet tools for network information retrieval.. Electronic Freedom Foundation. http://www.eff.org (5 May '96). The homepage for this website is a gathering place for anti-censorship activities. It is a well designed site that offers links to resources on issues related to freedom of expression. The EFF Archives is an electronic civil liberties library that has a searchable index. Some of the major archive topics include: computers & academic freedom, censorship & free expression, net information & online community, e-journals and EFF Staff/Board writings. The writings of the staff and board of EFF is an excellent resource for those interested in the rights and responsibilities of users of electronic networks. Mike Godwin is Staff Counsel for the Electronic Freedom Foundation, and also writes extensively on issues related to the Internet. He is a columnist for Internet World, and many of his writings can be accessed from this website. In the article, "Children, Child Abuse, and Cyberporn: A Primer for Clear Thinkers," Mike Godwin offers a legal explanation of what kind of pornography is considered illegal under the law, and what the indecency standard means with regard to on-line communication. Godwin also downplays the threat of child molestation on the Internet as being much less of a threat in the on-line world than in everyday real life situations. The information professional should be familiar with the Electronic Freedom Foundation as a major voice against censorship. Many related sites link to this website, and its staff and board members are often referred to or cited in Internet discussions. Elmer-DeWitt, Philip. "On a Screen Near You: Cyberporn," Time (July 3, 1995), 38-45. This article merits required reading status since it has provoked a great debate on the Internet. In general, public opinion seems to agree that the information in this article is a good example of mis-information or dis- information. Philip Elmer-Dewitt based his conclusions of widespread erotica on-line from a research study from Carnegie Mellon by Martin Rimm. The article says that 83.5% of all the images on Usenet are pornographic. This alarming figure has been widely criticized as a distortion. The Time article led the reader to believe pornographic images made up over 80% of the entire Internet. It failed to explain the difference between Usenet groups and the Internet as a whole. In any case, this article is necessary reading for information professionals who need to understand what sparked the Cyberporn debate. See also The Internet Advocate for critiques of this article. Hoffman, Donna L. and Thomas P. Novak. Project 2000 Research Program on Marketing in Computer-Mediated Environments. The Cyberporn Debate. http://www2000.ogsm.vanderbilt.edu/cyberporn.debate.cgi This excellent website was recommended on the American Library Association site, specifically on a page prepared by the Office of Information Technology Policy. The resources presented on this site provide extensive information on the cyberporn debate that includes Marty Rimm's Georgetown Law Journal paper, "Marketing Pornography on the Information Superhighway," and Elmer-Dewitt's Time cover story on cyberporn. In addition, there are numerous critiques of these two articles as well as media coverage of this controversy. A link to The Carnegie Mellon Censorship Page is available and provides CMU administration's response to the Rimm situation. This page also includes CMU policy statements on the ethical conduct of research. Hoffman and Novak's website presents a section about proposed government regulation on controlling access to the Internet. There are other Net links to the Cyberporn debate as well as links to other organizations that are involved in issues related to freedom of expression on electronic networks. This website is not to be missed for it is a very thorough resource on the cyberporn debate. The references cited are comprehensive and have been well researched. Student Access to Undesirable Materials. http://www.ncsa.uiuc.edu/Edu/ILM/CAUM/CAUM.html (5 May '96). This site supplies another resource page that links the user to materials that provide information on student access to controversial material. It addresses the censorship debate, acceptable use policies in schools and software filters that have been developed. The Education and Outreach group at NCSA (National Center for Supercomputing Applications) created this resource page to help parents, educators, and administrators understand issues relating to student access of undesirable materials. This website was included for the information professional because of two useful links. A link to Censorship, Freedom of Speech, Child Safety on the Internet lists resources that express various viewpoints about what needs to be done with objectionable material on the Internet (http://www.voicenet.com/~cranmer/censorship.html). Secondly, a link to Child Safety on the Information Superhighway links one to an on-line pamphlet produced by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (http:www.missingkids.org). The brochure was written by Lawrence J. Magid who is a syndicated columnist for the Los Angeles Times and has his own home page (http://www.larrrysworld.com) which deals issues relating to children and Internet usage. The pamphlet has a good discussion of issues and guidelines for allowing children access to the Internet. Magid discusses the benefits and risks of the Internet, offers guidelines for parents to help reduce risks when children use the Internet, and lists rules for online safety that will help children as they use online services. This website offers information professionals an additional reference source that explores access issues. The links on this resource page make connecting to this material easily accessible. The site may be especially useful for referral to parents and educators interested in information about commercial software filters. Wired. http://www.hotwired.com/wired (21 April '96). The archives of this on-line magazine are a good resource for material related to freedom of expression. The archive is searchable, and articles are easily viewed on-line. HotWired is definitely against censorship of the Internet, and the archive provides a great deal of information supporting this viewpoint. "The Rogues Gallery", for example, reveals which legislators promoted the Communication Decency Act. The e-zine also gives the reader updated releases about censorship issues. A transmission from the Communication Decency Act Information Network on March 14, 1996 could be viewed the day of issue. This recent transmission was from a news bulletin about Representative Anna Eshoo's introduction of the Online Parental Control Act of 1996. The purpose of this legislation is to eliminate the "indecency" standard from the Communication Decency Act and promote the development of technologies to utilize parental control of on-line material rather than governmental controls. For the information professional, this e-zine acts as an additional source of current information about online issues and freedom of expression.